Petunia's Secret

[cybermarmy]

No: HPFGUIDX 110422

caesian <caesian at y...> wrote:
<snip theory and explanation>
> 
> So, to conclude, Petunia is keeping a very big secret and it has 
> to do with the pact she sealed by giving Harry the protection of 
> her house.  What it is can only be guessed at now, but recent 
> comments by the author suggest that we will discover there is more
> to Petunia than it now seems.
 

Marleen replies:
 Caesian that was fantastic. I thoroughly enjoyed reading your 
theory! When I came to the end it made me think that maybe the 
secret that Petunia has, with a pact with DD, is that she was the 
one that told Voldemort(not really realizing it) where her sister 
and family were. Think about how much she disliked her sister, etc. 
Maybe she was too stupid to know what the outcome would be. Maybe 
Sirius was only a scapegoat. DD did know he was innocent, but it was 
more important to keep Harry safe because of the prophecy. I know it 
sounds far fetched. What do you think?