Why Harry will Live

[Josh Warren]

No: HPFGUIDX 110582

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "misty_december" 
<misty_december at y...> wrote:
> Josh:
> <snip>
> > it IS possible that the final battle may 
> > yield a survivor, but there are no guarantees.
> 
> ******************************************************
> So that would mean that they must both die at the same instant.  
> Otherwise, one is going to survive

Not at all... one must die, the other *may* die... perhaps at the 
same time, perhaps 5 days later, perhaps at some unrelated time far 
in the future... but 'at least' one will die in battle... or the 
battle will be refought.

> I knew I was terrible at logic.  LoL!  

:) So are 99% of everybody else. :) jk! It can be very hard to apply 
strict logic... especially when you are simultaneously stretching 
your imagination. Then you get into how tricky the English language 
can get, and how often it is used by 99.44% of its speakers, and you 
see the problem... :)

Josh, who is having a lot of fun with the prophesy tonight!