Marrietta's betrayal

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 110876

> Del replies :

snip.


> Knowing what went on in a person's head *is* critical when judging 
them.
> 



Alla:

Eh, yes it is critical, but it is POSSIBLE to render a judgment 
without knowing it. It could be an incorrect one, but, why not?

What Marietta did (her action) could be called "obeying a law". 
Sure, why not? But I can also call her ACTION " betrayal of her 
friends" That in itself is enough for me to strongly dislike what 
she did without knowing what she thought at the moment.

If I ever learn that Umbridge blackmailed her or torutred her in any 
way, physical or emotional, I will acquit her. :o)
For now, in my mind, she is guilty. ;)


By the way, Harry was definitely stupid for forgetting that Snape is 
a Member of the Order, but why is he stupid for rushing to save his 
godfather? He rushed to save his loved one. That was an attempt of 
noble action. How is it stupid?