Clue Behind the door -- female? (Re: Harry and Floo, Continuing Potions and The Clue)

[cristelmc]

No: HPFGUIDX 110952

> "uath50":
> - I think that the person that is described, is Luna Lovegood.  
> - Who says that the clue isn't a woman or a girl.
 
> Amey:
> The clue behind the door??? It can't be a woman, there is a *he* in 
> bracket. And I am sure JKR is not going to mislead us to that extent. 
> The person in the clue is a *he*, and if we read it right, he is HBP 
> or is somehow important. 


cristelmc:
I agree with Amey. Any clue JKR has ever given us has been spot on. 
It may take some serious homework to figure out sometimes but JKR 
would never lead us astray. She said the person is a he so he is in 
fact a he. JKR will not fib about the sex of someone just to lead us 
off trail. She wouldn't bother with the clues at all if she didn't 
want us guessing in the right direction.