Snape and Regulus Black (was Snape & the Edinburgh Festival

[imamommy at sbcglobal.net]

No: HPFGUIDX 111137

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "barbara_mbowen"
<barbara_mbowen at y...> wrote:
 Put 
> this together with my favorite theory about Regulus Black, that he
is, in fact, in 
> hiding as the reclusive Stubby Boardman (who retired from his career
as a 
> rock'n'roll singer after being struck by a radish at a concert). 
His retirement 
> from singing was just at the same time as he was allegedly killed: 
some 15 
> years before.  Never mind Voldemort, he knows better than to come
out of 
> hiding while Snape is still out there.  He's hiding from the DE's,
he's hiding 
> from the MoM and he's most of all hiding from Snape.
  
> 
> Marmelade's Mom

imamommy:

Let's tie another idea to this:  Regulus as the one "who has left me
forever.  He will be killed, of course."

I think most of us agree that Snape is too obvious a conjecture to
actually *be* this one, and this may provide a better theory to who
this "one" is.

imamommy