harry is tom riddle
Jim Ferer
jferer at yahoo.com
Wed Aug 25 22:46:51 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 111226
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Miller, Gina (JIS)"
<ginamiller at j...> wrote:
> Time travel was a key in PoA, yes, but I don't really think you can
> say it's key to the series. Iprefer to stick to more conventional
theories.
>
> Gina :
> * AS DO I and I sincerely hope that it stays conventional and
> does not get so far out that it ends really badly just to keep us from
> guessing the end. But the prophecy was worded that way for a reason and
> Harry and Tom Gina:"Gina : * AS DO I and I sincerely hope that it
stays conventional and does not get so far out that it ends really
badly just to keep us from guessing the end. But the prophecy was
worded that way for a reason and Harry and Tom look alike, both speak
Parseltongue, both have matching wand cores, and we never got a good
reason why that name sounded familiar to Harry. I REALLY TRULY hope
this is as far out as it sounds or I would really be disappointed, but
come now - "Why didn't LV die" - why did Harry live? "Why wouldn't DD
kill LV in the DoM" it is all a little strange to me."
Did you know that JKR has explicitly denied (in the "Rumours" section
of her website) that Voldemort (and therefore Tom Riddle) is not
Harry's father, and has also said that James Potter definitely is
Harry's father?
I don't understand why it's strange to you that Harry lived - that's
been explained. "Why didn't DD kill LV in the DoM" has also been
explained from DD's own lips. And it makes sense: Dumbledore knows
there is only one that can destroy LV - Harry.
Jim Ferer, who believes that LV is not naturally "alive" anyway, his
existence sustained only by magic.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive