The graves of James and Lily

cubfanbudwoman susiequsie23 at sbcglobal.net
Thu Aug 26 13:54:31 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 111285

kizor0 wrote:
> > > To date, the graves haven't turned up anywhere in the books. 
> > > Visiting them would probably be an important event for Harry, 
> > > and distances don't matter all that much in the WW, so is it
> > > possible that this will become a Future Plot Point(tm)?
 
Terpnurse wrote:
> > I remember during the filming of PoA, I had heard or read that 
> > Cuaron wanted to put a graveyard into the movie on the school 
> > grounds and that JKR nixed that, citing a specific place on the 
> > grounds where there *is* a graveyard and that it will come into 
> > play in a later book. I've wondered since then if perhaps the 
> > elder Potter's graves are there.
 
 
vidar_fe writes:
> The problem with the "Lily & James are buried at Hogwarts"-theory 
> is:  Why hasn't Harry visited their grave yet? I mean, he's been 
> there for  five years, if his parents' grave is anywhere near the 
> castle, I can't believe he hasn't found it yet. It is so unlikely. 
> And besides, the house in Godric's Hollow burned to the ground, 
> perhaps the bodies where destroyed?


SSSusan:
LOL!  Why wouldn't Harry have visited them?  Because Harry never asks 
questions!  [Damn him!]  How much has Harry EVER really asked about 
Godric's Hollow?  To our knowledge, he's not asked for specifics, 
he's never asked where his parents are buried, he's never expressed 
an interest in visiting their graves (if they exist) nor Godric's 
Hollow itself.  Many of us go NUTS over this aspect of Harry's 
personality.  As likely as not, it's as much JKR keeping things from 
us as Harry's "true personality," but still....

Seriously, with all H/R/H's wanderings, I do understand what you're 
saying about its being unlikely that they've not stumbled across 
this...but given that the Hogwarts graveyard has never been mentioned 
by anyone in 5 books, maybe it's tucked away somewhere on the edge of 
the grounds?

As for the bodies of James & Lily, this was just posted in 111273 by 
DuffyPoo:
"I set out for your parent's house straight away. And when I saw 
their house, destroyed, and their bodies -- I realized what Peter 
must have done. What I'd done." PoA - The Servant of Lord Voldemort.

Siriusly Snapey Susan






More information about the HPforGrownups archive