Percy's Letter (Was: Is Percy a spy?)

[potioncat]

No: HPFGUIDX 111297


> Potioncat:
> > The other thing is, he may not be a spy for the Order, but just 
> > for Dumbledore...in the same sense that Snape wasn't a member of
> > the Order in the first war, but worked for DD.
>  

Totorivers: 
>   Ahem, how do you know that about Dumbledore and Snape? 

snipping a bunch of good points

Potioncat:
We know that DD vouched for Snape saying that Snape had provided 
service at risk to himself.  We also know that certain members of 
the Order did not know that Snape had been a DE nor that Snape had 
served DD prior to LV's fall.

I'm basing that on the GoF Pensieve scene. And several discussions 
between Black-Lupin-Harry.  Though I'm not sure of which books.

As to your points about Percy, I'll take a closer look at him.  I'm 
in GoF now. 
Potioncat