Snape's DE past

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 111481

> Magda: 
> 
> Hey, reality bites, doesn't it?  
>snip.

>> I don't think Harry is so fragile that he can't handle the truth 
and
> both versions of James are true - one version from a friend, one 
from
> a non-friend (enemy sounds too heavy).  
>


Alla:

If it is the reality. I will ask you that question again at the end 
of book 7. :o)

I don't care what Harry can and cannot handle. Snape's behaviour is 
inappropriate regardless, IMO. Yes, Harry is not Neville (although I 
bet that in the book 6 Snape's insults will not get free pass from 
Neville either), but it should not matter, IMO.
 
>> Magda:
> 
> Again, I assume you're referring to Snape ending the occlumency
> lessons?  Am I right?


Alla:


Yes, of course. Sorry!


Magda:
 snip.


 Stopping the occlumency lessons did not leave
> Harry any more vulnerable than he already was.




Alla:

We don't know that. Yes, of course there is a big chance that he 
still could have that vision, OR he might have accomplished better 
results in Occlumency by that time.

I think it left him significantly more vulnerable