[HPforGrownups] Lupin visiting Sirius at Azkaban

Alina alina at distantplace.net
Mon Aug 30 06:13:49 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 111585

> sad1199 here:
>   If one of my very best freinds supposedly betrayed one of my other
> very best friends and the other best friend ended up dying... I
> think I would find that former best friend and confront them. I
> would beg and cry and yell and plead to find out what had happened.
> Now, it says in the books that Fudge visited Sirius in Azkaban and
> Crouch and his wife visited their son and did the big switcheroo.
> WHY DIDN'T LUPIN GO ASK SIRIUS WHAT HAPPENED? Yes, I am yelling.
> This is truly irritating me. In my fifth reread of PoA and have so
> many more questions now than before. I just can't belive that Lupin
> didn't go to Azkaban and confront Sirius.

I can theorize that maybe because he's a werewolf he's not allowed to go to
certain places, like Azkaban? Maybe the Potters and Sirius weren't the only
ones suspecting Lupin of being a spy either, so he could've been in hiding
or avoiding persecution when it first happened and when he finally could go,
he didn't think there'd be enough of Sirius left to answer any questions.

alina.






More information about the HPforGrownups archive