Lupin visiting Sirius at Azkaban

mrs_sonofgib tinainfay at msn.com
Mon Aug 30 12:00:08 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 111601

> sad1199 here:

>   If one of my very best freinds supposedly betrayed one of my 
other 
> very best friends and the other best friend ended up dying... I 
> think I would find that former best friend and confront them. I 
> would beg and cry and yell and plead to find out what had happened.
> Now, it says in the books that Fudge visited Sirius in Azkaban and 
> Crouch and his wife visited their son and did the big switcheroo. 
> WHY DIDN'T LUPIN GO ASK SIRIUS WHAT HAPPENED? > 

Tina here:

Fudge wasn't visiting Sirius, he was inspecting and Sirius asked for 
his newspaper.  He was there in an official capacity.
POA Am PB 209  "Yet I met Black on my last inspection of 
Azkaban....  He spoke quite rationally to me."
As far as the Crouch family goes, Crouch was allowed a visit to his 
son because he was a higher up Ministry official.  GOF Am PB 529  
Sirius notes "Crouch being an important Ministry member, he and his 
wife were allowed a deathbed visit."  
So, this makes me wonder if visitors are allowed at all?  We do not 
know what was going on with Lupin either way - would he have liked 
to confront Sirius (but was unable to) or is he just more a head-in-
the-sand type?  
~tina






More information about the HPforGrownups archive