The Darkness Within

spacedoutspacecadet spaced_out_space_cadet at hotmail.com
Wed Dec 1 06:00:56 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 118941


 
Jeane said:
> Remember in Lord of the Rings, the same thing was said of Gollum 
> by Gandulf: what in fact happened was Gollum bit Frodo's finger off 
> to steal the ring.  That turned out to be a good thing but it 
> doesn't come under "I owe this guy so I will help him out." type of 
> act.  It may be Peter tries something nasty that turns out to be 
> helpful.



Hey everyone, 

Thanks for replying. I do like the whole Lord of the Rings similarity 
and it does seem a possible thing to happen, though I do have to 
wonder (after she has received a lot of criticism for other 
similarities) if she would do that. Then again it would be just like 
Peter to try something nasty, fail miserably and end up doing 
something heroic.

I personally am not a fan of little old Peter and as such would love 
to see Remus while in wolf form tear him to shreads! However that 
brings into question the whole problem with the silver hand, 
something that I know has been discussed in great detail... so I wont 
get on that topic.

I do suppose that I should have lumped Fudge into the 'good' 
characters with darker sides, any thoughts on what will happen to 
him??

Anyway thanks for the thoughts!

Spaced Out Space Cadet :):)












More information about the HPforGrownups archive