Slytherin (was Re: Problem with OotP?)

[Juli]

No: HPFGUIDX 119050


Juli earlier:
> I don't think just because someone is Slytherin he/she is evil, there are good Slytherins, like Snape (I just love him), and Phineas Nigellus.

Renee replied:
> Was Phineas Nigellus reallyu a `good Slytherin'? He's called the worst Headmaster of Hogwarts ever. Isn't he (or his portrait) honour-bound to help the present Headmaster? What would he do if he wasn't?

Juli again:
Phineas may not have been the best Headmaster
(actually he was the worst, according to Sirius), but
does it mean he was evil? No, why would the WW allow a
evil dark lord to teach their offspring? I don't know
what year was it, but unless the world was mostly evil
back then, the MoM would never let an evil wizard be
Headmaster at Hogwarts. By the way, I think Phineas is
really cool, the way he tells Fudge that he may not
always agree with DD, but you can't deny he's got
class. I just loved that. 

Juli