Harry's Protection (was Re: Questions)
Jen Reese
stevejjen at earthlink.net
Sat Dec 4 16:26:27 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 119245
Snow:
<snipping>
> The room at the DOM is said to 'contain' this force
but it is also
> said that it is the 'power' that is 'held within this room' that
> Harry possesses in such great quantity that Voldemort detests. The
> room therefore contains a force 'and' holds a power. We may be
> dealing with two separate states of matter; the one that Harry
> possesses and the one contained in the room.
<snip>
>
> In the end my suspicions would be that immortality is the force
that
> can be more wonderful and terrible and the power is `pure' self-
> sacrificing protection.
Jen: This is good, Snow! My first thought was, "but Harry isn't
immortal" then I realized you're saying the power Harry possesses in
great quantities is essentially the opposite power from the one that
drove Voldemort to seek immortality. And you make a good case for
immortality being more wonderful and terrible than any other force.
I do wonder though, since it's a power Voldemort 'detests' whether
we're not back to the idea of pure Sacrificial Love (SSSusan's gets
the nod here) and not just pure self-sacrifice. Harry has definitely
shown over and over he is willing to sacrifice himself, most notably
in OOTP when Voldemort possesses him. But it was Harry's feelings of
love for Sirius and total lack of fear of death that ultimately
drove Voldemort away in that instance.
To me, self-sacrifice must be for a greater or higher purpose to be
something other than killing yourself. I'm not trying to sound tacky
there, but do you know what I mean? True, pure self-sacrifice is
about Love in the end.
And then there's the question of how Harry came to have this power
and Voldemort not at all. Did Voldemort reject this power in his
quest for immortality or never have it to begin with? We know he
wasn't born evil, he must have possessed this power in *some* small
quantity at least.
Jen Reese
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive