Surprise me, dammit !!!!!

[imamommy at sbcglobal.net]

No: HPFGUIDX 119306


--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "samnanya" <yswahl at s...> wrote:
>> What is far more interesting (to me at least) is plotting. What 
> SUPRISES do you think JKR has in store for us frantic desperate 
> readers? What plot twists can bring the series to a memorable and 
> satisfying conclusion? What lessons does JKR want to teach her 
readers 
> by the actions of the characters in the potterverse? 
> 
> Remember, there has to be at least SOME canon to support a suprise, 
> otherwise you have a deux ex machina and everyone tosses the book 
> against the wall.... (i.e. End of book 7 --- and Harry woke up and 
it 
> was all a dream told to him by his scar)
> 
> And the thing about suprises, if they are obvious they are not 
> suprises. Also, and this is important here ..... THEY DONT HAVE TO 
> HAPPEN !!! THEY JUST CANT BE DISMISSED OUT OF HAND. 
> Dont tell me that Lupin CANT POSSIBLY be evil since he reminds you 
of 
> your ninth grade teacher and HE was a good guy, or whatever built 
in 
> opinion you have based on your life experience .... 
> 
> So..... what SUPRISES do YOU think might happen?
>

imamommy

Just last night I posted a plot theory that either no one read, or no 
one liked, because nobody replied to it.  In either case, I would 
really like some feedback on the idea.  I contend that somehow 
Voldemort will lose his soul to a Dementor's kiss, probably while he 
is posessing Harry.  Harry will then be the only person to be able to 
tell us what it feels like to be Kissed by a Dementor, and Voldemort 
will be worse than dead.

Here is my support:

1. Harry would have to face his greatest fear, and that makes sense 
structurally, especially from a hero's journey POV.

2.  DD did promise LV a fate worse than (physical) death.

3.  JKR promised us that Harry would be getting another kiss, but she 
didn't say from whom.  She said it in relation to a SHIPping 
question, but I think she was misdirecting us.

My former post on this subject is #119223.
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/HPforGrownups/message/119223

imamommy