[HPforGrownups] Re: Petunia and Voldemort (was Various)

[Juli]

No: HPFGUIDX 119616



> Ginger said:
> >...edited...
> >
> >Perhaps LV killed the parents to show Petunia his
> power, and then
> >(instead of trying to AK her) tells her that if she
> doesn't give him
> >the answers he wants that the same fate awaits her
> and/or Vernon and
> >Dudley.  She would have been far willing to take in
> Harry to be
> >pretected from LV, if this was part of the deal.
> 
Janet replied:

> Another possible flaw is that if Voldemort wanted
> answers from either 
> Petunia or her parents, he would get more use out of
> an Imperio than out of 
> an AK.  He'd then know for sure that they did not
> know where the Potters 
> were. Not that he might not kill the parents on
> general principles (or to 
> try to flush the Potters out of hiding) ...
> 
Juli:
But do you think Petunia would have taken Harry in to
her home if she had "really" known what LV can do? The
letter from DD must have said something like, LV
killed Lily, take care into you home and only there he
will be safe from any dangers. She took Harry AFTER LV
was gone, so there really wasn't a lot of danger (at
least to some), So my guess is that she took Hatty
only because once she loved her sister. Thinking about
Janet's idea, Do we know if muggles can be imperio'd? 

Juli


		
__________________________________ 
Do you Yahoo!? 
Yahoo! Mail - now with 250MB free storage. Learn more.
http://info.mail.yahoo.com/mail_250