Dudders and the Dementors
imamommy at sbcglobal.net
imamommy at sbcglobal.net
Sat Dec 11 04:31:14 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 119691
>
> Tammy replies:
>
> Good catch, indeed it's true that the dementors "dissolved into a
> silver mist" before Mrs. Figg makes her entrance. Harry even takes a
> moment to contemplate before Mrs. Figg comes running in.
>
> I still think Mrs. Figg lied though, if only from her behaviour at
the
> hearing. Plus, could she really have seen the whole thing happen? If
> she did, why did she stay away, why not come up and give Harry at
> least moral support?
>
> -Tammy
imamommy:
Or started shouting for Mundungus earlier? For anyone who used to
watch Bewitched, I keep expecting him to turn up and say he's been in
Bombay;)
My guess is that if she felt the effects, but couldn't actually see
the dementors that 1) she felt too horrible to help Harry or 2) she
realized too late what was going on.
I think if DD had instructed her to lie, he would have told her more
about the way dementors move. I think she did this on her own.
imamommy
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive