I don't like him much

barbarahanson alexpie at aol.com
Wed Dec 15 21:45:20 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 119945


Kneasy wrote:
>> Young Potter is the eponymous hero and the viewpoint we get from 
the 
> books is his. And not by any stretch of the imagination can that 
> viewpoint be considered as unbiased. If Harry doesn't like 
something, 
> then it must obviously be wrong; if somebody disagrees with Harry, 
then 
> they are wrong. Rubbish. Harry is the one that's usually wrong - 
with 
> unerring and boring predictability.


Thanks, Kneasy!  This first hit me when Snape, in PoA, told Harry off 
for sneaking into Hogsmeade, which made Harry livid; yet, when Lupin 
said almost the same thing to him a moment or two later, he was 
contrite.  As seen through Harry's filter, Snape was wrong and Lupin 
was right!  This pattern has continued throughout, and it will cost 
perhaps him, and certainly others, the same price that Sirius paid 
when Harry "forgot" that Snape was in the Order and ran off to save 
the world himself.
Ba







More information about the HPforGrownups archive