Questions

[chrusotoxos]

No: HPFGUIDX 120042


--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "vmonte" <vmonte at y...> wrote:
> 
> Some Harry Potter Questions I Want Answers to:
> 
> 1. Has Lupin ever killed anyone while in werewolf form?

According to me, no. Lupin talks profusely about his problems as a werewolf, and I'm sure we could have seen the shadow of a regret if it had been there. The closer he came was when he almost murdered baby Snape. And, we know that the Wolfsbane was not available when he was at Hogwarts, but it was probably invented not long afterwards, so...
But this point will be important - you don't create a werewolf to let him sit in a chair. :))

> 2. Was Lupin a werewolf on the night that Lily and James were
> killed?

No again. He was suspected, remember? Therefore, he had to be in his human 
form to be able to go to Voldemort and betray the Potters.

> 3. Is the voice that Harry believes to be his father telling his
> mother to run (dementor scene in PoA) really James? Or, is it
> another case of mistaken identity?

It is. Lupin is sure of that, and he would know how things happened from Dumbledore. And who else could have been?

> 4. Will Voldemort get his hands on a time turner?

Time-turners are overrated.

> 5. Will Harry travel back in time and be mistaken for James?

No. It's apparently difficult enough to be himself. And, he couldn't fool people who really knew James well.

> 6. Is there something in Snape's worst memory that Snape does
> not want Dumbledore to know?

No. Dumbledore had seen it all when Snape was a student.

> 7. Did Sirius's prank against Snape happen on the night of the
> school exams (Snape's penseive memory)?

I really don't see Snape trust Sirius's information after the events of that day, but miracles will never cease...

> 8. Who were Lily's best friends?

Had she any? Shouldn't we know about them by now?

> 9. Whose brain attacked Ron? (Flamel? Godric?)

They wouldn't use such valuable things for experiments, imo. And how they were able to keep Godric's brain from the Middleages?

> 10. Will Harry eventually be able to do magic without a wand?

No. JKR said that real magic always requires a wand.

Ok, here is my guess. Now answer me this, it's obsessing me: did Lucius teach Snape all those drawling tones and silky voices? The self-assurances, the 
feline grace? Was he trained that way in order to fight as a Death Eater? Are they friends?

Chrusotoxos