Is Snape really that good at Occlumency?

[LadyOfThePensieve]

No: HPFGUIDX 120093


Hello Lupinlore,

when I read your statement I wondered how much more false a statement
as yours can be? You oversee some crucial points. First at all! Harry
took a look into the Pensieve (Snape´s Worst Memory). When he saw
what
happened to the 15 years old Snape it did not happen in the
Occlumentic lesson, but after Snape left the room.
When Harry shortly penetrated Snapes mind, Snape stopped the
penetration after a very short while (Seen and Unforseen).
So you see, you are putting things together which neither happened
under the very same circumstances, nor do you make any detailed
distinctions. 
I really love the HP books and do really wonder why people are so
biased when they judge specific circumstances in the books. Your view
makes me wonder how much stupid Dumbledore can be up to your eyes?
Trying to take revenge on a fictional character is petty at all events
from my point of view.
You call yourself Lupinlore. If you want to learn something from him
then to be much more detailed and much juster.

Calm down a little bit.  Greetings from Austria.