Theoretical boundaries

dumbledore11214 dumbledore11214 at yahoo.com
Tue Dec 21 23:10:11 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 120327





FFred:

snip.


...I'd far rather try to understand the characters from their own 
perspectives and those of the world that they live in (which at least 
for wizards are completely alien to our own) than to get umpty 
because some of them would fall foul of the
authorities in our world.


Alla:

You see, I am of the opinion that WW values are MUCH closer or WILL 
be closer to ours than JKR lets on. If I thought that that world is 
indeed so different from ours , I would read those books quite 
differently.

But I think there IS a reason why JKR keeps saying that she does not 
believe in magic and that we will have to wait and see what happnes 
at the end.

I think there IS a reason why despite the fact that to majority of 
her peers Hermione looks quite annoying with her SPEW efforts , JKR 
just won't let it go.

I think there IS a reason why despite the all around discrimination 
of werewolves, we know of one werewolf who was allowed  to attend 
Hogwarts and one headmaster who made it possible

I think that constant presence of the phoenix in the series IS the 
hint that WW will undergo radical change in the moral, ethical sense. 
See Pip's wonderful post. This is the only part of MD, which I 
strongly agree with.

What am I getting it? Oh, yes, I think that at the end of it all, WW 
will be VERY close to the moral values of us, muggles or actually to 
the moral values of the "potterverse" creator.

But it is just my opinion, of course and I can be very wrong.


Alla,

who just like everybody else cannot wait till July 16 comes. :o)










More information about the HPforGrownups archive