Did Snape Try to Warn James at GH? (Re: Here is an interesting Snape one)
Jen Reese
stevejjen at earthlink.net
Fri Dec 24 20:14:52 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 120544
> > Kneasy:
> > This one would certainly work in plot terms, matching known or
> > suspected character traits to the action - though there's one
> little question that Mooseming doesn't address - who gave Snape the
> Potters location?
> Valky:
> Ohhh yes Easy Kneasy!, Snape is doing his spy work glued fast to
> Voldys swishy cloak, when he happens upon a crumpled piece of paper
> that fateful night, he craftily sneaks a peek and finds it to be a
> note, written on parchment that bears the very insignia of the
> Potter family itself, on it is written, "The Potters are located at
> number street Godrics Hollow", of course.
> And voila Snapes conclusion that the one who betrayed James was
> someone so close to them he could use the Potters own parchment and
> seal to do it.
> Of course this way he doesn't have any idea precisely *who* it is
> that wrote the note, but it does seem more likely to be Sirius.
>
> Hey, then again, maybe the note was written on Parchment bearing
the
> seal of the Noble house of Black. Peter did plan to frame Sirius
> from the start, I believe.
Jen: Aha! The missing link. You're the crafty one, Valky ;).
What time of day Snape goes to the Potters is the key. Peter betrayed
their location sometime on Halloween, but we don't know how long it
was between the time Peter left his secret location to tell
Voldemort, and Sirius found Peter missing. Peter could eaily have
left his hiding place Halloween morning, expecting to be back when
Sirius checked on him that night. Instead, something blocked him from
returning.
So, like you postulated, Snape comes across the note Peter gave to LV
disclosing the Potter's location, and Snape immediately rushes there
in an attempt to get James & Lily to another location. When James
refuses to believe Sirius would betray him, Snape leaves in disgust.
Not long after that, LV appears.
I tend to take it at face value that James was the voice Harry heard,
and that if Snape did go to the Potters that night, he was gone
before Voldemort showed up. We already have canon evidence from the
Occlumency incident that Snape is willing to give up on a vitally
important task if he is humiliated. If James humilated him at GH,
Snape would most likely chalk it up to Potter arrogance and leave.
Jen
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive