Harry's cupboard was Re: Theoretical boundaries
pippin_999
foxmoth at qnet.com
Sun Dec 26 16:54:40 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 120617
> Alla:
> I think Lupinlore has a point though. Dursleys told Harry what
to clean and where to clean, right? Do you think they would
permit him to make his living conditions more tolerable even if it
involves his labor only? I think they would not allow that if only
out of spite, JMO.
>
> I hope you are enjoying the holidays.
>
Pippin:
Thanks and the same to all. I don't have PS/SS handy, but I
am sure there's something in there about Harry sneaking out
after the Dursleys go to bed to steal food from the kitchen. That
shows that a) he wasn't routinely locked in and b) he wasn't
totally supervised. One could speculate that Harry brought
stolen food back to the cupboard to eat, and the crumbs drew
flies, which in turn supported the spiders, and Harry was happy
to have them since he found the spiders less annoying than the
flies.
Also, I took "dark" to mean windowless, not that there weren't any
lights in there. As I've pointed out before, a windowless bedroom
isn't a bad idea if there are wizards after you who have
to be able to see you to curse you. In any case, Harry had to
have a lighted place to do his Muggle school homework.
Since Harry is within an inch of his father's height, his growth
was not stunted -- he was just small and skinny for his age,
especially if his standard of reference was Dudley.
Pippin
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive