Snape at Godrics Hollow

[ms_luna_knows]

No: HPFGUIDX 120621


-> > 
> > Luckdragon:
> > I have been posting the unpopular theory that the Potters were in 
> > possession of the P/S stone at the time of their demise. If <snip> 
> > Snape was there to warn the Potters it would make perfect sense that
> > he would have collected the stone and taken it to Dumbledore. <snip> 
> > Either before or after Hagrid collected Harry Snape would have snuck
> > in and retrieved the stone.
> 
> 
> Ms. Luna:
> 
> If Snape snuck in and retrieved the stone, why wouldn't he have also 
> taken Harry?  If Snape really wanted to prove himself to DD, he would 
> have collected both the stone and Harry.  
> 
> Luckdragon:
> 
> Hagrid arrived before he had the chance and Snape not yet sure what exactly had just 
>happened to Lord V waited and was surprised to see first Hagrid who collected Harry,
>then Sirius who gave H his bike then took off after Peter. Remember there is lots of
>distrust, deception and confusion. No one can be trusted until Snape is sure
>Lord V is gone.
 


 Luna,
But, if the theory is that Snape were there to warn the Potter's of
LV's impending visit, he/
Snape would have gotten there right before LV, and would have most
likely been the only 
one to witness the distruction of GH.  I can't imagine that Snape
wouldn't have figured out 
that everyone in the house was either dead or gone (based on
Hagrid's description).  At 
that point he would/should have been the only one there to run in and
retreive the stone 
(if the Potter's ever had it, which I am not completely sold on) and
Harry. In any event, 
I hope we will all learn of the events at GH in the HBP.