[HPforGrownups] Remus and Sibyll sitting in a tree ( wasRe: Trelawny real...

[chnc1024 at AOL.COM]

No: HPFGUIDX 120819

 
In a message dated 12/30/2004 4:55:53 PM Pacific Standard Time,  
vmonte at yahoo.com writes:

vmonte  wrote:                                                                
                                  <snip> Not so much that he is ESE LUPIN!, 
but more like 'I may 
have  killed a friend or Order member while I was a werewolf' kind of 
thing.  Wasn't there someone in Moody's picture who all they found of 
him was  pieces? Was he killed by a DE, or by Lupin? I don't know why 
I feel like  Lupin feels guilty about something. And what are the 
chances that he's  never killed?


***************************************************
 
Chancie:
 
I don't know if I think Lupin feels "guilty" because he killed someone or  
maybe
its just the fact that he blamed Sirius for James's death. He thought  Peter 
was dead, and maybe he felt as though he should have done something to 
stop it.  Then felt guilty because when he learned Sirius was  innocent, that
he blamed him in the first place. Do we know if Lupin really had any  other 
friends other than the Marauders?  Maybe he felt he couldn't really be  
friends 
with others for fear of killing them durring the full moon.  After he  left 
Hogwarts
I doubt he had a safe place for his transformations like the Shreeking  Shack 
provided.  I guess what I'm trying to say is that maybe his guilty  feelings 
are 
just because he feels responsible for the deaths of the others.  Like  Harry 
felt
for Sirius's.  That maybe if I had done something diffrent my friends  would 
still
be alive.
 
Chancie


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]