OOP weather
ghinghapuss
rredordead at aol.com
Sun Feb 1 01:12:17 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 90029
"Dysis" wrote:
> I have been re-reading OOP, and have noticed something that annoys
> me very much. In the beginning of the book, we learn that there is
a severe drought. <snip> Okay, so we learn that there has been no
water for a while and that the heat is unbearable.
>
> When Harry is on the Hogwart's Express, he notices some rain clouds
> gathering in the distance. Later, when he gets off the train, Harry
> notices the Thestrals. Their breath forms mist in the chilly night
> air. In the first week of the school year, it rains profusely.
Every time Harry looks outside, it's drizzling. Even Ron notices
this. So what's the deal? How come there is such a drastic change in
weather?
> True, the months are different (the drought takes place in
June/July while the rain is in September). But September isn't all
that cold. Something is not clicking here. JKR mentions the weather a
lot in this book. I became annoyed with the constant reference to the
rainy weather. She obviously wants to draw our attention to it. I
don't have any solid theories about this yet, but could it be LV?
Maybe he's demonstrating his new powers. Or maybe it could be some
wizards who were tired of the constant heat. They're not very good
theories, I know, but I still have to work on them. Any ideas about
this?
Mandy here:
Two words: Great Britain!
Sorry to disappoint, but I don't think there are any hidden messages
in the constant references to rain by JKR. The weather is a constant
source of conversation in the UK. Just like the Eskimos have
something like 50 words for snow, so the British have an umpteen
number of words for rain. And yes, the weather changes drastically
at the drop of a hat.
I had the pleasure of growing up near Salisbury Plain, the site of
Stonehenge, and if you want unnerving and freaky weather experiences,
go and visit the famous stone circle. You can actually see weather
change before you eyes; clouds forming in an otherwise clear sky and
pour with rain before clearing up and disappearing, all within the
space of an hour. Quite spectacular really and easy to see how
ancient peoples though the area was magical. Well, it is magical,
but that's a whole other converstaion.
Our weather stinks but we have the greenest country in the world and
great skin because of it, so I can't complain.
Mandy
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive