The Historical Geography of the Wizarding World
Susan Miller
constancevigilance at yahoo.com
Sun Feb 1 18:05:26 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 90049
--- Andrew Greaves wrote:
There are only five known Wizarding Schools, canonically located in
Brazil, France, New England, Scandinavia, and Scotland respectively.
Constance Vigilance (me):
Actually, canonically, we have only THREE Wizarding Schools, and the
locations of THOSE are in dispute. I think we all agree that Hogwarts
is in Scotland, but we don't have absolute canonic proof of even
that. That Beubatons is in France is also likely, but it could be in
French-speaking Belgium. While I firmly believe that Durmstrang is in
Scandinavia, there is much disagreement on that accord among our
listees who have made good cases for Eastern Europe and northern
Russia.
I don't know your reference for a school in Brazil, but I suspect
that arguments could be made pro and con on that regard also.
As for the existance of a school in New England, I think there is
very likely to be such a school, but we have no canonic proof of any
school in North America. We do have a cluster of quidditch fans at
the World Cup from the Salem Witches' Institute, but that isn't a
school, it's a social club for women. It's a JKR joke based on the
Women's Institutes in the UK. Did you see the movie Calendar Girls?
It's about a fund raiser at a Women's Institute. At the World Cup, we
even have the visitors from the Salem Witches' Institute *knitting*,
emphasizing the women's focus of the Institute.
I did enjoy your post, though. I think you have some good insight on
the geographic history of wizardry.
~ Constance Vigilance
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive