Despised Lackey or Social Equal?: Snape's 'Respectability'
Julie
inky_quill at hotmail.com
Mon Feb 2 20:01:56 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 90108
I'm fairly new at posting, so I hope you'll all forgive me if this
question has been raised before. And pardon the long windedness.
I was following the recent discussion about Professor Snape's
supposed "desire" for the DADA position (Good points
all),when a point was raised as to whether or not Lucius Malfoy
considered Severus Snape of sufficient social standing to treat as an
ally vs. a lackey, and that the way Draco "sucks up" to Snape might
indicate his family doesn't "look down on Snape socially".
What I've been wondering aboutand perhaps those of you
familiar with class structure and the British boarding school system
could sound in where would Snape's position as Head of Slytherin
House place him in the social context of Wizarding Britain in
general? Ignoring Snape's unpleasant appearance and demeanor, what
type of status does a "job" like Head of House confer as opposed to
just being a Potions professor/Master?
Social prominance or "status" usually derives from a couple
different things, which I imagine holds true in Wizarding Britain,
too.
A) there's the old standby of wealtheither commercial prosperity or
land, with land being by far the preferred and respectable source of
wealth.
B) family lineage: pureblood vs. less pure or muggle born. I assume
that within the pureblooded families there is a whole separate
hierarchy based on ancient lineage, direct descent, famous magical
ancestors, service to the crown/ministry of magic (ie the Ancient
House of Black, and the Tom Riddle's reinvention of himself as
a "lord")
Or should I say three sources of status? There is also: C) amount
of magical power.
Wealth: We don't know from the books whether Snape has any
income beyond what he earns as a potions instructor at Hogwarts (I
wonder what the remuneration at such an exclusive school would be
like?). He may have additional income derived from being a Potions
Master (publication royalties, patents, consultation fees) or an
inheritance.
Family Background: I tend to agree with whomever said Snape's
memories indicated a non-elite background, although I didn't take his
spitting at the Quiddith match as proof (spitting + sports just seems
to be a guy thing and I took it solely as a sign of spur-of-the-
moment intense contempt). Since he was a Death Eater, he surely
claims some degree of pure wizardly heritage.
I tend to read Snape (his dress, speech patterns, method of teaching,
emphysis on respect and obedience) as someone with a chip on his
shoulder, who's self-made (or re-invented), who has struggled for
what he has and is very much on guard against loosing it, rather than
born to wealth and power and easy social connections like the
Malfoys.
Magical Ability: We've been told Severus Snape is a very powerful
wizard, and at a fairly young agehe's not yet forty in a potentially
150+ life spanso we can probably safely assume that he's not yet
reached his peak ability. He is also one of an exclusive and limited
number of specialists in his field in Britain. Snape lacks the
trappings of pretigious power that Lucius Malfoy displays, yet we
really don't know how the two compare magically.
So taking any combination of the sources of status where does that
leave Snape?
Since Hogwarts is the only school of its type in wizarding-Britain,
am I safe in assuming that means any other magical training would be
viewed with suspicion and prejudice? Not quite "the thing"?
Wouldn't this increase the prestige of being one of the four
Heads of House? Would the Board of Governors have to approve an
appointee as Head of House, or would it be solely at Dumbledore's
discretion? Or would there be a board within a board composed only of
former Slytherins who would have to approve, just as Ravenclaws or
Hufflepuffs would approve a new Head of thier houses? Or would the
other heads or even the Sorting Hat decide in a vacancy?
So I wonder. Would a combination of magical abilities, and what must
be at least a respectable bloodline (perhaps a bastard branch or
tradition of vassalage to a `good' pure blooded family?) plus Head of
House be enough to place Severus Snape on equal footing with someone
like Lucius Malfoy?
Snape is able to project a strong aura of power and intimidation in
the books, besides the added impression of residual DE nastiness that
Harry and gang know about from his past, but set that aside (and it
can be as he was very careful, almost meek, in his dealings with
Doris Umbridge). Unaware of any Death Eater connections or Snape's
reputation as a cold and nasty character, would someone like Lucius
Malfoy or Neville's Grandmother, or Amelia Bones consider Snape
of 'respectable' or 'proper' social standing? Or would he only be
held in respect by other Slytherins (whose children he is
overseeing/training, and even post-Hogwarts he would retain some
power as Head of House for things like references and word-of-mouth
recommendations)?
Regardless of how Lucius and Severus interacted in school or as
fellow Death Eaters (or spies), Lucius has a child who is sorted into
Snape's House. I would assume that regardless of how the two men
personally get along, Lucius would at least feign cordiality while
Draco was in school, and somewhat vulnerable to his Head of
House's wrath or interference.
Consequently the younger Draco would "suck up" knowing that if he
could gain his Head of House's favor it would make his Hogwarts
career much easier. (I imagine there's a separate course of study
for young Slytherins called Manipulation and Self Preservation 101).
I don't think we've enough canon evidence to state that Draco
believes his father and Snape are `friends' or that he knows that
Snape was/is a Death Eater. I agree that there seems to be some form
of interactions between Snape and Malfoy, Sr. due to Umbridge's and
Sirius' remarks, but I think Lucius has kept the younger Draco
isolated from the realities of the Death Eaters(per Draco's speech in
the Slytherin common room during the polyjuice adventure in CS). It's
more that Snape and Malfoy are fellow Slytherins and part of an "old
boys network" that share certain values, which Draco assumes he'll
one day take his own place in.
Would anyone care to comment? Offer corrections on assumptions?
Julie
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive