Squib or muggle - who's a late bloomer?

justcarol67 justcarol67 at yahoo.com
Tue Feb 3 02:46:21 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 90136

lizvega2 wrote:
I was rereading some random JK interviews, and in one quote she 
said 
that someone very late in life (No specific age given), who has 
never shown any ability for magic previously, will be able to do 
magic in very desperate conditions. 
I'm sure it's been discussed, but anyone have a thought on who 
this could be? 
 
Debbie R responded: 
> The "Mimble Wimble" thread suggests that it might be Vernon Dursley.  
> Though Aunt Petunia comes to my mind as well, given that she seems to 
> know a bit more about the WW than we ever thought she might.  I 
> believe that either one is a distinct and likely possibility. I look 
> forward to future revelations on their backstories.

Carol:
If the List Elves will forgive me a short post, we've recently gone
through this topic at least twice. The prime candidates are Filch and
Mrs. Figg, both squibs (and both considerably older than the
Dursleys). Muggles (including all of the Dursleys) are nonmagical
people, by definition unable to become witches or wizards at any point
in their lives.

Sorry I don't have time to look up the relevant posts, but you can
probably find the Petunia and Mrs. Figg threads easily enough by
looking at the Message Index for the last few weeks even if the Search
function is still acting up.

Carol, who is trying to catch up and finding it difficult to lurk







More information about the HPforGrownups archive