From Black to White and back to Black (was Peter...)

[ghinghapuss]

No: HPFGUIDX 90384

Mandy wrote:
> > So, even if it can be proved that Black is dead, which it nigh 
> > impossible as Carol clearly points out above, how can DD 
convince  Fudge and the WW that he was really fighting on the good 
side?   <snip>  Harry is Sirius' only hope, and I believe he is 
going to  channel a lot of his anger in to clearing Sirius name 
eventually, but for now he's got a lot on his plate to deal with.

> "K" wrote:
> Do we even know yet that Black was not a DE or that he really was 
on the side of good? IMO we don't.  
> Barnes and Noble Chat/20 October 2000
> Is Sirius Black ever going to be cleared? 
> JKR: Can't tell you, that's too important a bit of information!


Mandy here:
Damned good point!  I handn't put much thought into a ESE/Sirius 
idea. But would Harry accept it?  Would we?  More importantly could 
JKR really do that to Harry and us???

Do you have a past post on ESE/Sirius?  I would love to read it.  
Mandy