Could Lily have trained to be an Auror while Pregnant?

elihufalk elihufalk at yahoo.com
Wed Feb 11 15:26:57 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 90726

Mandy:
> I have these dates:
> Lily left school in 1978 (from Lexicon)
> Auror training: 1978-1980 (my speculation)
> Got pregnant Sept/Oct 1979 (logical deduction from date of birth)
> Gave birth July 1980 (from Lexicon)
> 
> So this only give her just over 1 year of physical freedom 
> to train. Summer 1978 – autumn 1979. Also bear in mine she 
> was a member of the Order during this time and actively fighting LV. 
> 
> I do see Lily as a superwoman, and I want to believe it is possible 
> as I'm a young woman and want to be able to do it all, but I just 
> don't see how she could have done it.  


There is, in my opinion, a mistake in the Lexicon's claim that Remus 
Lupin Went to Hogwarts in the 70's. Prof. McGonagall became a teacher 
39 years before OP; She teaches transfigurations, the same subject 
that Dumbledore taught (CS); so Dumbledore must have stopped teaching 
that by 1956 (assuming Harry was born in 1981).

Remus Lupin stated that Dumbledore "became" headmaster shortly before 
he went to Hogwarts. That would put the year he began at 1960 at the 
latest!

Now, James and Lily were of the same year as Lupin, therefore the 
years when Lily could have finished school were before 1970.

                                           Elihu






More information about the HPforGrownups archive