Apparition
severelysigune
severelysigune at yahoo.co.uk
Mon Feb 16 10:41:48 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 91044
Arya wrote:
<snip>
<<Why do Order members arrive at HQ via the front door and even ring
the door bell, waiting for someone to let them in when Fred and
George show us that Apparition is possible within the house?
<snip>
Is a just something that allows them to Disapparate and Apparate
while remaining within the house? If they can do this, why do Order
members not simply pop in and out without risking being seen outside
as they enter or take the time to wait for someone to answer the
door?
There must be something that makes it impossible for the Order
members to not pop in and out--it's far and away a better way to
travel and less risky than arriving by the front door. >>
<snip>
Sigune here (without answers, alas, and straying slightly off topic):
Personally I do find it rather reassuring to see that it is
apparently impossible to Apparate inside this house when you travel
there. I have often wondered while reading how wizards and witches
secure their privacy.
I mean, Floo sometimes works as a kind of telephone; but the person
who tries to contact you either stands right in your fireplace or
peeps directly into your house at least. Likewise, a person can just
Apparate into your house. How to ward off unwanted visitors then? A
Muggle can simply refuse to answer the phone or the doorbell; the
person calling cannot know the other one is at home or not. I would
hate the idea that it is possible for someone to literally pop in at
any given moment, whether you feel like entertaining them or not.
So:
Would there be a) restrictions to Floo use (e.g. can you 'shut down'
your fireplace?); b) courtesy rules (e.g. you are supposed to
Apparate at the front door rather than inside a house when you go on
an unexpected visit); c) specific (household; not just the very
intricate ones no doubt at work in Hogwarts) charms to keep people
from dropping in at random; d: other?
Yours severely,
Sigune
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive