Harry's eyes was Re: The colour "Purple"
meriaugust
meriaugust at yahoo.com
Mon Feb 16 14:50:59 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 91051
snipping out the first half of the post to answer this one:
>
> Also, I have read that Harry's eyes are weak, and that JKR stresses
> the importance of his glasses. I wonder what is so important about
> ordinary, and probably cheap, muggle glasses. Why and how are they
> important? Why are Harry's eyes so weak? Is it just a normal muggle
> optometry problem?
>
> Sawsan
Well, I think there are three reasons for the stressing of the
glasses. A: It shows that magic is not a cure all, even for
something as simple as nearsightedness (or whatever it is that Harry
suffers from). If wizards as powerful as DD and McGonagal can't just
point their wands at their eys and say a spell and be good as new
then how can magic be expected to cure more complicated ills, like
death? B: Glasses give our great hero, Harry, a weakness than a lot
of kids (myslef included) can relate to. I had a pair of thick
plastic specs when I was in elementary school and was taunted for
them, so I get why Harry is made fun of in his pre-Hogwarts days,
and I am sure a lot of kids out there do, too. (I am pretty sure
there is a quote to the effect of, "no one liked that wierd Harry
with his baggy clothes and taped up glasses" at the end of the
Vanishing Glass in SS). And C: That Harry wears glasses shows that
despite the general lack of care given to him by the Dursleys, there
was enough attention paid there for his eye problem to be diagnosed
and dealt with. I know that my eye problem was caught in my pre-
Kindergarten physical, so Harry clearly had at least that
rudimentary medical check. Whether Aunt Petunia and Uncle Vernon did
this only to keep the muggle authorities off their backs, or because
back when Harry was five the threat of intervention by a pack of
wand brandishing wizards was for more real than later in Harry's
life, I leave to JKR to explain.
Meri
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive