Time turner problems (Was: PoA Plot does not work)

[dorapye]

No: HPFGUIDX 91223

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "justcarol67" 
<justcarol67 at y...> wrote:
>> Carol:
> Which leads me to wonder what exactly happened to the baby-headed
> Death Eater in the same scene. Has anyone figured out who he is?
> Obviously not Bellatrix, but I've also eliminated Nott (knocked out
> earlier), Malfoy, Dolohov, Rookwood, Avery, and MacNair (all of 
whom
> Harry recognizes or would recognize), and Jugson who was paired 
with
> Dolohov and must be the one hit with the Petrificus Totalus spell 
at
> about that same time. I don't think it's Crabbe, whom he might have
> recognized by his build, and it probably isn't one of the Lestrange
> brothers, who were probably the two following Bellatrix. I think 
that
> leaves just Mulciber. Has anyone else tried to figure this out? 

dorapye:
Carol, there is a very thorough, blow-by-blow analysis of the fight 
in the DoM on the Lexicon site (go through the What's New icon to 
find it - its quite recent).  I *think*, though I may be remembering 
it wrongly, that the man who wrote this essay concluded that the 
baby-headed DE was indeed Crabbe Snr, but it is best to dig through 
his evidence and see if you agree..

dorapye