Apparition & Fidelius Charm
Sharada
bumchum22 at yahoo.co.uk
Wed Feb 18 22:41:45 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 91249
Hi,
I have not mailed the group, I guess as I am a reader more. But this one intrigued me too much and I wish to share my view on it as well.
Fidelius Charm is a form of secret keeping and the secret is stored in one person. The secret and the secrecy is revealed to whoever only if the carrier of the fidelius charm wishes to. This, to my understanding, and I am sorry I dont have the books to refer to at this point of time, means that the place or the substance or the secrecy is not revealed by anyone else. In support to it, if Harry was to tell this address anyone else, they would either not remember what he says, or words dont come out of Harry or the most probable being, they will not be able to find the place. But I still feel he just won't be able to say or write(saying comes out as different words or sounds and writing probably same way or invisible).I think in Oop, it says even though Kreacher could not say the location of the order and its activities as he is under fidelius charm, he could still reveal usefull information. So this makes me very sure that, by no means can the information go out through anyone but the
secret keeper in a comprehendable way. I hope I was clear I my views above. Any questions mail me. So, by her mere genius, or through intelligence of some DE, if Bellatrix did find out that no. 12 Grimmauld place was the headquarters, I am sure she will not be able to go inside(even with Kreacher's help or following anyone).
Apparition.(Again, everything is only my view).
Apparition can be done with others(holding others) and disappear. But I am sure that the Potters didnt do it to risk their sons life. As p\mentioned earlier, I think you will need highly experience, powerfull wizards and witches to do it. But there are other ways of disappearing,like what Dumbledore did after his fight with Mom in his office. He didnt and couldnt have apparated as it cannot be done in the grounds of Hogwarts(Hogwarts, A History). So Voldemort could have used these means to get out with Bellatrix.
The members would have apparated to the house, HQ of the order if it had been possible. May be once inside you could do it, but not from outside. Or just that JKR has not mentioned it and it might still be possible.
Harry's Fav.
---------------------------------
How much mail storage do you get for free? Yahoo! Mail gives you 6MB! Get Yahoo! Mail
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive