Harry and the Dark Arts

antoshachekhonte antoshachekhonte at yahoo.com
Thu Feb 19 22:15:33 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 91308

"jozoed":
> Has anyone considered that after the events in OOTP Harry may, for a 
> short period, be tempted by the Dark arts? He has suffered more than 
> most wizards ever have in their lifetime, he is angry and tormented 
> by his fate and the circumstances in his life. I am not suggesting he 
> joins Lord V, but is there a possibility that he turns his back on 
> doing 'good', detaches himself from Dumbledore, and for a time 
> becomes entangled in his grief for Sirius, refusing to battle on as 
> the 'hero'?


I hate to go cross-series, but doesn't that sound very Return of the Jedi? As for his 
moodiness and withdrawal, as someone who works with teens, I have to say another 
book's worth of teen angst is about the only thing (aside from a huge sappy turn-around 
by Snape and/or Malfoy) that might make me even consider putting the series down. Well, 
maybe not... but I could do without quite so much of it!

Rebellion, maybe, but moping and sulking, ick.

AC






More information about the HPforGrownups archive