The tragedy of Ron Weasley

oogems7 oogems7 at yahoo.com
Sat Feb 21 05:50:25 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 91366

"Christopher Nuttall" wrote:
> In GOF, she dates Krum - who sees Harry as a potential rival - and 
> in the COS movie, hugs Harry and refuses to hug Ron. Ron must be 
> very jealous of them, even though Harry and Hermione are not lovers,
> Ron may well suspect them to be.  Ron's comments at the end of OOP 
> about Ginny dating someone better, said with a sharp glance at 
> Harry, could be interpreted as an attempt to set his rival up with 
> someone else.
> Harry has the girls (in Ron's eyes) - Ron is too shy to ask a girl 
> out...  Harry has no family to look down on him - Ron's family are 
> a weight around his neck...
> Look at this and ask yourself; would you not be bitter too?>>>
 

Oogems says:
You know you should read post 39362, it goes into great length, and 
detail about how Lupin is a DE, it nearly convinced me.
You have done something similar here, taken a seed and grown a 
forest, so to speak.  
We have seen no canon evidence that he is that weak of a wizard 
(compared to the average of his class) nor have we seen anything to 
suggest that intelligence has an effect on a wizard's or witch's 
(cough Hermione cough) level of power.
We might (probably) see another fit of rage in him, but I doubt that 
it will be on the level you suggest.  It is rather normal teenage 
behavior.  There is also the fact that JKR will most likely not 
repeat, for a third(?) time, another traitor plot line; she uses 
things only twice, at most.

Oogems
On a side note, I'm all for Hermione getting a wake up call.  After 
OotP that girl is going to have a level of arrogance (or belief in 
her own smarts, and being right all the time) that would put Draco 
to shame.  I've learned my lessons in life, I greatly respect strong 
women; she however, is over the line.







More information about the HPforGrownups archive