Harry's Eyesight - basilisk protection?

carrilynne carrilynne at sbcglobal.net
Sun Feb 22 22:26:20 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 91447

Grannybat:
> > <snip PoA quote>
> > It's possible that you need to look directly into the eyes of 
the victim to use certain spells, and looking at the eyes through 
clear solids (eg. windows, eye-glasses etc.) isn't good enough. 
Maybe the presence of glasses protects his eyes from such spells.

Neri now:
> In OotP, the first Occlumency lesson, Snapes explains to Harry 
> that "eye contact is often essential to Legilimency". 
Unfortunately 
> for your theory, Harry most probably had his glasses during this 
> lesson and it did not protect him from Snape.


Carri now:
So, would his eyeglasses have protected him from the basilisk 
stare?  Since CofS shows only petrification occuring when seeing the 
eyes through something else, for example, water on the floor, mirror 
(which are reflections) and a ghost and Collin's CAMERA - not 
reflections.  Looking THROUGH the lense of the camera protected 
Colin from death, so could eyeglasses be a form of protection in 
some future appearance of another basilisk?
~CarriLynne






More information about the HPforGrownups archive