[HPforGrownups] Re: How many prefects per house?

silmariel silmariel at telefonica.net
Mon Feb 23 14:18:59 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 91478

Potioncat:
> I think James' saving Severus from the werewolf had something to do
> with Dumbledore's decision.  

I've never considered James a saint for saving Snape. He just saved his neck.

If snape had died... all the marauders would be in Trouble, and the school 
also. Unregistered animagi, to start. Sirius framed with murder (I don't know 
in which grade) and in this case, being guilty. Remus with blooded hands and 
fangs, proving *why* werewolfs are dangerous and giving reasons to the 
anti-werewolf party to ask for 'werewolf containment measures'.

And Lily would see James in another light, that's sure, if he had let another 
student die.

But then, after saving him (if it is the truth that he saved him) he might 
have reconsidered his life and character.

Silmariel




More information about the HPforGrownups archive