Faking Sirius' Death?

[confusinglyso]

No: HPFGUIDX 91507

> In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com,
>
>::Entropy::
>entropymail <entropymail at y...>  starting with post #91486
>
Phil (confusinglyso)
You have covered some of the ideas I posted on some months back but 
your post is much better written and has justifiably elicited more 
responses.
I think Sirius' death is faked and I also think that the Weasleys in 
the Order, apparently missing from DoM battle are in fact on the 
other side of the Veil, to receive Sirius.
I will list my earlier post numbers so that any linked threads can be 
followed.
#76403
#77937
#83373 with some flippant ideas
#83734 the Veil is a 2Dimensional object with 3D capabilities
#83946
#85269 if really are dead people beyond Veil.

I find the earlier scene at the Veil interesting, particularly where 
Harry thinks he hears Ron beyond the Veil. This I have interpreted in 
2 different ways in the posts listed.

The general consensus on this site is that JKR said in an interview 
that Sirius is really dead.  Is it allowed for fans to be misled by 
interviews ?
I don't mind if Sirius is dead or alive but from book alone, the true 
canon, the reader cannot be certain either way on Sirius' health.


Phil