Faking Sirius' Death?

[c_robocker]

No: HPFGUIDX 91588

"jozoed" wrote:
> Here in the UK JKR has given several interviews describing her 
> reasons for Sirius' death. 
<snip> 
> > 
> >
> Entropy responded: 
> JKR's interviews describing the writing of Sirius' death are 
> certainly canon for his death being permanent.  
> > 
> <snip>
> 
> Carol:
> I think the voices behind the veil and Luna's faith that she'll see
> her mother again are reflections of JKR's own Christian beliefs.


I hated to snip all the good discussion out, but for the sake of 
brevity... 

I agree that I first thought of the reflections of Christian beliefs 
that Carol mentions.  

The other phrase that JKR said in an interview was that 'it has to 
be' when referring to the death in Book 5.  I don't think that 
Sirius's death has been faked, neither am I convinced that 
he's 'properly' dead although I am convinced that Harry will not see 
him again in the flesh.  However, I take her comment in the 
interview to open the possibility that Sirius can and will do 
something from where ever (or *when* ever) he is, that is crucial to 
the plot.  

-CRobo, wishing she had more evidence to support or destroy the 
theory!