HOW many classmates? All things are Relative
suehpfan
stanleys at sbcglobal.net
Wed Feb 25 19:06:25 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 91645
snip
Bboy_mn wrote:
> Greatest number = Hufflepuff
> Somewhat Large = Ravenclaw
> Small = Gryfindor
> Small = Slytherin
>
> Just off the top of my head, I would guess a ratio of
40H/30R/15G/15S.
> I can't prove that ratio, so it's more of an illustration of my
point
> than anything else.
>
>snip>
> bboy_mn
This would also be a reasonable explanation as to why Gryffindor
never has classes with Ravenclaw. There is one problem with your
theory (which I happen to agree with), the Sorting Hat says in OotP
it has to "quarter" the students each year. This would indicate that
the division would be fairly equal. There are also many references
to the tables in the Great Hall during feasts and they are always
full. JKR never mentions that there are significantly fewer students
at Gryffinder or Slytherin tables.
In another post (who knows where I wrote it, it could be in OT
Chatter) I mentioned that the sheer size of the dormitory would be
astronomical if there are approx. 30 students per year per house. In
Gryffindor alone the boys tower would have 3 floors per year meaning
a tower of 21 stories (1 tower each for boys and girls) assuming that
each dorm room held 5 students. Not only that, but crowding in the
common room takes on a whole new meaning with over 200 students
crammed in.
That said, in JKR's world they can fit what, 10 people in a Ford
Anglia? So I guess anything goes.
Sue, who would ask JKR *exactly* how many Gryffindors there are in
Harry's year, along with all of the other questions mentioned.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive