Why not floo instead of thestral to London?

suehpfan stanleys at sbcglobal.net
Thu Feb 26 18:49:35 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 91698

Snip of previous posts
Snip of Carol's excellent post about the mirror
Carol wrote:
 I thought it was a very moving moment and underlined the whole idea 
of how our choices,
> and our mistakes, have unintended and unanticipated consequences. 
*If
> only* he'd at least opened the mirror and known it was there. *If
> only* he'd used it to talk to Sirius instead of talking to the
> treacherous Kreacher. But with the mirror as well as the journey to
> the MoM, he did the wrong thing for the right reason and suffered 
the
> consequences of human error.
> 
> snip

Sue:
Another consequence of the same action was that the world now knows 
Voldemort has returned.  As the story goes this is probably the most 
important consequence of not using the mirror.  If Harry had 
discovered Sirius was safe, he would have known Voldemort 
was "messing with his head" and would not have gone.  We would have 
another year of "hem hem" and horrid things being said about Harry 
and Dumbledore.  

Perhaps then, it could be said that Sirius's life was sacrificed to 
save the WW and more specifically, those people he cared most about.  
Not such a bad reason to die, really.

Sue





More information about the HPforGrownups archive