The eavesdropper: DD plant

spang_b spang_b at yahoo.co.in
Fri Jan 2 04:05:19 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 87943

 "confusinglyso" <pjcousins at b...> wrote:
>Fracas to eject "eavesdropper" could cause trance to be broken.

  Well,the text itself says that the one who was listening was thrown 
out. But it doesn't specify who did the throwing. I mean, somebody 
else might have been there, like Hagrid who might have spotted this 
man eavesdropping and threw him out. Alternately, it doesn't require 
that at all. After Dumbledore realised somebody was eavesdroping, he 
just might have conjured a spell that threw this fellow. That 
wouldn't break Trelawney's attention, would it?

spangb
  








More information about the HPforGrownups archive