GOF: US Murder vs UK Curse

justcarol67 justcarol67 at yahoo.com
Mon Jan 5 20:23:24 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 88117

Eloise wrote:
<snip>
 
> GOF was published simultaneously in the US and in the UK, so
manuscripts 
> which still potentially contained errors and which needed final
polishing were in 
> the hands of both of publishers at the same time. We have an example
of an 
> authorial error treated differently by the respective publishers in
the wand 
> order mistake, which got through in first editions of both versions
and which was 
> subsequently corected by Bloomsbury but not (AFAIK) by Scholastic.
>

I just checked my Scholastic edition, which I thought had been
corrected. Nope. Harry's mother appears before his father in the
Priori Incantatem scene (Am. paper back ed. 667). Does anyone know if
there are differences between the American paperback and hardback
editions? Maybe the error has been cleared up in the hardback? If not,
someone should write to Scholastic about it--and about the
murder/curse blunder, too. It never occurred to me that my own
confusion over that scene resulted from an error in "translation"!
Thanks to all involved for asking and answering that question.

Carol





More information about the HPforGrownups archive