house elves and laundry (house elves and goblins)
drjuliehoward
drjuliehoward at yahoo.com
Wed Jan 7 19:23:38 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 88202
<Snip>
Carol wrote:
Hermione wouldn't know about House Elves before coming to Hogwarts
> before she's a Muggle-born and probably assumed (as we did if we
> thought about it) that the laundry was done by magic. (Actually, it
> probably is--just not by the Wizards themselves.) And the author of
> "Hogwarts, A History" is not so much "colluding in . . .
oppression"
> as simply taking for granted a thousand-year-old tradition, much
the
> way we Muggles take electricity for granted. In describing a
friend's
> home, we wouldn't say, "The house had electric light and a washing
> machine." It would never occur to a reader that it didn't.
>
>
Yes, that makes sense. That led me to another series of questions
and wondering if there is any canon evidence/answers:
1. How long has this system been in place if it is "taken for
granted" by the WW?
2. If this is the system, why don't all wizarding families have
house elves? Why is this for the financially privileged or for
institutions such as Hogwarts?
3. Prior to their enslavement, could they have been PAID assistants
(which would, in some ways, answer Q2)?
4. If they were paid, what happened to their money?
5. Which brings me to this: House Elves and Goblins look a lot
alike. Could the goblins have something to do with their
enslavement?
I know this is bordering dangerously to being OT, but in my mind it
would set up an interesting rivalry between these two groups in
another wizarding war. Many posts have speculated about goblins and
house elves and where their loyalties may fall, but I have not read
any posts addressing any possible connection between the two
groups. Any ideas?
Julie
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive