genealogy of Harry Potter:

Kelly Penn hermione978 at yahoo.com
Sat Jan 10 21:45:10 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 88410

Geoff:
> I think the question of who can touch the prophecy refers to
> the /initial/ picking up and not later. Voldemort has been thwarted
> because he tried to get it via someone else; this failed because of
> the protection so he lured Harry to the MoM for that purpose. He
> could have got it himself but this would have confirmed that he had
> returned.


Yes, he did try to use Neville to get the prophecy, but if you re-read 
the last part of O of P CAREFULLY Dumbledore tells Harry that the prophecy could most likely be him, but maybe not which is where Neville Longbottom 
comes in.  This is a definite clue and unexpected thing in JKR's writing. 
It is worth noting.   

Hermione978





More information about the HPforGrownups archive