Weasleys as heirs of Slytherin? Was: Why put the entrance to the Cos in a gi
Berit Jakobsen
belijako at online.no
Sun Jan 11 00:23:16 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 88413
Carol wrote:
And Dumbledore (presumably a pureblood himself) states
unconditionally that Tom Riddle is the last descendant of Slytherin.
So unless he's wrong, the Weasleys can't be heirs of Slytherin, and
if Harry is, it's only via the transferred powers of Voldemort.
Berit replies:
Where old Dumbledore is concerned, one should take more notice of
what he is not saying than what he is saying... :-) He rarely tells
the whole truth; just ask Harry! So Dumbledore saying Voldemort is
the last descendant of Slytherin could be just part of the picture.
When did DD ever present the whole picture? He never has. I'm not
saying he's lying; rather that he just chooses to hold back some (or
lets say most) of the truth for the sake of the readers' suspense :-)
Berit
http://home.no.net/berjakob/snape.html
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive