Vamp 'til ready
Danielle
strom5150 at charter.net
Mon Jan 12 03:44:11 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 88483
Kneasy wrote (heavily snipped):
> > Fair do's; I've offered arguments as to why Snape isn't a vampire.
> > Now it's your turn; show me why Voldy isn't.
I've read other posts comparing Voldy to a vampire, and your post
sums up all of those points nicely. So, I have nothing from canon
to offer you proving he's not one.
I only offer to use your own anti-Snape!Vampire argument against
you:
In what way would Voldy being a vampire aid or enhance the plot of
the books at this point? And why, if Snape should be a human with
human motivations for his nastiness, etc. instead of a vampire, is
this not also true for Voldy? He is, or was, human. And Tom Riddle
proved that Voldy's evilness was brewing nicely while he was still
fully human. So, why a vampire now?
Danielle
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive