Which House were James, Sirius, and Remus in?

[catherinemckiernan]

No: HPFGUIDX 88578

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, aiiesdelamour at a... wrote:
> In a message dated 1/12/2004 5:25:43 PM Eastern Standard Time, 
> christyj2323 at y... writes:
> Second, I can NOT see Remus Lupin as a member of Slytherin house. He
> has none of the qualities for that. Remus is... well... almost
> anything but a Slytherin.
> 

Crystal then wrote (hi Crystal)...

However, a part of me still refuses 
> to entirely give in to the theory, and I agree that Lupin is one of
my primary 
> reasons for it -- I could see Remus easily being a Ravenclaw, but
that aside, 
> I think he would belong in Gryffindor.
> 
> I just don't see him as having the qualities that would make the
Sorting Hat 
> choose to place him in Slytherin, 

(snipped further Sirius-related Gryffindor thoughts)

Now me...

Hmm, Remus is the tricky one, because he doesn't obviously fit the
qualities of cunning and ambitious. However even attempting to conceal
the fact he's a werewolf is an ambitious undertaking, and to manage to
do it (alone at first, then with help from his friends) takes cunning.
Moreover if all 4 of the gang and Snape were in Slytherin together, it
might explain why the 3 top dogs are friends with Peter ? they're
isolating Snape by gratuitously being friends with everyone except
him. It would also explain how Sirius in GoF knew the identities of
Snape's Slytherin friends. 

Ultimately, I sit on the fence, but I agree with those who think that
some sort of house surprise is definitely going to be sprung upon us.
What about sorting little Mark Evans in Slytherin?!

Catheirne McK